Despite this and despite recent legislative changes, the law is still in an unsatisfactory state, and the purpose of this article is to analyse the various issues. View notes the authority of company representatives and the turquand rule revisited. A comparative analysis of the provisions of the act on capacity and authority will be undertaken with reference to the south african companies act of 2008. In its simplest form the turquand rule, or indoor management rule, entails that if nothing has occurred which is obviously contrary to the provisions of the registered documents of the company, an outsider may assume that all the internal matters of the company are regular. Sa who has been lecturing and consulting on company law and secretarial practice since the new act was implemented and many years before that. The authority of corporate agents a forgery is not an exception to the rule in turquand b where the irregularity is of public record c the outsider must act in good faith.
It is also popularly referred to as turquands rule. The ultra vires doctrine and the turquand rule in company. Agency principles and the rule in turquands case volume 49 issue 3 l. The rule was enunciated by the court to mitigate the rigors of the constructive notice doctrine. Act provide that a person will have the usual authority of a director if his or her name appears on the public file. Lindgren this article is based upon part of the writers ph. Doc turquand rule statutory and common law revised. Turquand, was the case in which the rule was first enunciated and therefore, the locus classicus on this point. Does the section extend the turquand rule, and does it now allow a third party to presume the delegated authority of an individual director. Agency principles and the rule in turquand s case volume 49 issue 3 l. Cliffe dekker hofmeyr can the authority of a director be. Full text views reflects the number of pdf downloads, pdfs sent to. Wikipedia, lexilogos, oxford, cambridge, chambers harrap, wordreference, collins lexibase dictionaries, merriam webster.
The application of the rule in turquands case in present day. Estoppel, where the doctrine of estoppel can be used, is a further extension to the turquand rule, however, that is another topic in itself. It has become necessary to reexamine the issue of authority and representation in the sphere of company law as a result of the judgment of the. Companies act 71 of 2008 and the turquand rule by piet delport. Doctrine of indoor managementturquands rule youtube. There are various principles in the corporate world that help determine the relationship which ensures the safety of various stakeholders in the company in the transactions that they undertake. Cliffe dekker hofmeyr the turquand rule a question of. Clarification of the turquand rule when contracting with. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. This indoor management rule or the rule in turquand s case is applicable in most of the common law world. The turquand rule, agency principles and constructive notice will be discussed in so far as they relate to authority of agents. Blrt investments v grand parade investments ltd and others 2007 jol 19779.
It originally mitigated the harshness of the constructive notice doctrine, and. Listen to the audio pronunciation of turquand rule on pronouncekiwi. This document was uploaded by user and they confirmed that they have. Turquand this article is based upon part of the writers ph. The authority of company representatives and the turquand rule revisited. Indoor management rule board of directors legal concepts. Ruleauthority of the companydoctrine of constructive noticethe rule in turquands caseexceptions. Jan 16, 2009 if this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise cambridge core to connect with your account.
There are various indian case laws that approved and followed the rule. This indoor management rule or the rule in turquands case is applicable in most of the common law world. Pronunciation of turquand with 3 audio pronunciations, 1 meaning and more for turquand. Turquand 1856, the defendant was a liquidator of a mining and railway company. In the context of liquidation proceedings, the rule is generally known as the badenhorst rule from the leading eponymous case on the subject, badenhorst v northern construction enterprises pty ltd 1956 2 sa 346 t at 347h348c, and is generally now treated as an independent rule not dependent on.
Suggest taking any additional material from turquand rule and posting it as a subpara under royal british bank v turquand. The doctrine of indoor management, popularly known as the turquands rule initially arose some 150 years ago in the context of the doctrine of constructive notice. Universiteit van johannesburg companies act 71 of 2008 and. The effect of the turquand rule is that a third party dealing with a company has constructive notice of the internal formalities of a company required by its. Business law and ethics assignment help, exceptions in turquands case, exceptions. A minidissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for.
Doctrine of constructive notice and doctrine of indoor management. The rule in turquands case can operate in relation to any contractual obligation but has over the years frequently been raised in respect of a document to which the companys seal has been affixed. You can complete the definition of turquand rule given by the english definition dictionary with other english dictionaries. The turquand rule, corporate capacity and agency in south. Doctrine of constructive notice and doctrine of indoor.
Search turquand rule and thousands of other words in english cobuild dictionary from reverso. In that case, the royal british bank sued turquand as the liquidator of the coal brook steam, coal, and swansea and london railway co. In that case, the royal british bank sued turquand as the liquidator of the coalbrook steam, coal, and swansea and london railway co. But this is not to say that in some situations a company may not be bound by the rules of estoppel i. You can complete the definition of turquand rule given by the english cobuild dictionary with other english dictionaries. This item appears in the following collections research articles university of pretoria 19803. Agency principles and the rule in turquands case the. The rule that windingup proceedings should not be resorted to as a means of enforcing payment of a. The turquands rule has gained statutory recognition in section 9 1 of the european communities act, 1972. A close historical analysis of turquands case is crucial to a proper understanding of this area of law and will shed light on what has. The doctrine of indoor management is one such principle. The doctrine of constructive notice of a companys public documents was, of course, abolished prospectively. In retrospect, it can be seen that the scope and importance of the turquand rule seek to protect third parties from scrupulous activities by the company, its director, or any of its official agents.
Share page serious consequences can result when a person representing a company does not have the necessary authority. The question of authority came under scrutiny in a decision recently handed down in the cape high court. Companies act 71 of 2008 and the turquand rule request pdf. It stipulates that an outsider dealing with a company in good faith is entitled to assume that there has been compliance with the. Section 207 of the companies act, 20 makes a mention of this. Sa who has been lecturing and consulting on company law and secretarial practice since the new act was implemented and many years before. This doctrine is also termed as turquand rule and was enunciated in the famous and leading case of royal british bank v turquand in 1856. Using the url or doi link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely. The application of the rule in turquands case in present day company law. Knowledge of irregularitythe first and the most obvious restriction is that the rule has no application where the. It is a uk company law case that determined that people transacting with companies are entitled to assume that internal company rules are complied with, even when they are not. Because this is available for public inspection, people doing business with the company are free to inspect the document to see if there is any limitation. L shareholders rule more than a century and a half ago it was held in the english case of royal british bank v.
Unless anyone lodges any objections, im happy to do it. The memorandum and articles of association of a company has to be lodged with the registrar of companies. The plaintiff sued the defendant for repayment of money borrowed on a bond signed by the companys two directors and the secretary under a company seal. Thank you for helping build the largest language community on the internet. It provides a shelter and protection to the outsiders dealing with the company that are, in no way, bound to judge the regularity of the internal procedures of a company. Turquand 2, was the case in which the rule was first enunciated and therefore, the locus classicus on this point. Exceptions in turquands case, business law and ethics. This statement can be reduced to two propositions which constitute what is compositely known as the rule in turquands case, namely i. Turquand rule statutory and common law revised south africa. Delport, piet, companies act 71 of 2008 and the turquand rule.
Doctrine is also popularly known as the turquand rule. Corporate authorityand dealings with officers and agents larelle chapple senior lecturer tc beirne school of law the university of queensland and phillip lipton. Doctrine of indoor management,meaning, royal british bank vs turquand, exception to doctrine of indoor management. Professor gower, summarizing the common law position in 1969, stated. Turquand that a person dealing with a company in good faith is entitled to assume that the company has complied with its internal procedures and formalities. The turquand rule states that persons contracting with a company and dealing in good faith may assume that acts within its constitution and powers have been properly performed, and are not bound to enquire whether acts of internal management have been regular. The turquand rule, corporate capacity and agency in south africa. Knowledge of irregularitythe first and the most obvious restriction is that the rule has no application where the party affected by an irregularity had actual notice of it. It furthers the universitys objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide.
The high court of south africa western cape division, cape town in the matter between case no. Indoor management rule free download as powerpoint presentation. Introduction the rule in the case of royal british bank v turquand is commonly known as turquands rule or the indoor management rule. Doc the turquand rule statutory and common law junior b. The authority of company representatives and the turquand.
The general rule is that if an agent is unauthorised, he does not validly bind the principal and accordingly no valid contract is concluded with the principal. The case clearly has no significance outside the rule and vice versa. The doctrine of indoor management, popularly known as the turquand s rule initially arose some 150 years ago in the context of the doctrine of constructive notice. The rule in turquand s case can operate in relation to any contractual obligation but has over the years frequently been raised in respect of a document to which the companys seal has been affixed. The person suing the company is in fact an insider, such as a director of the company. Universiteit van johannesburg companies act 71 of 2008. A company is aa company is a voluntaryvoluntary association of personsassociation of persons formed for theformed for the purpose of doing business, having apurpose of doing business, having a distinct name and limited liability. Oxford university press is a department of the university of oxford. In the recent high court decision of one stop financial services pty ltd v neffensaan ontwikkelings pty ltd and another, the court confirmed the requirements for reliance on the common law turquand rule as well as the implications of the statutory turquand rule in respect of individual directors who purport to bind a company. The rule in turquands case the case of royal british bank v turquand 2, refined the basic common law of agency to articulate the doctrine of indoor management.
Mar 07, 2012 delport, piet, companies act 71 of 2008 and the turquand rule february 6, 2011. The affixing of the seal brings into play the different principles of company law. Business law and ethics assignment help, rule in turquands case, rule in turquands case. Doctrine of constructive notice the memorandum of association of a company has to be lodged with the registrar of companies. Search turquand rule and thousands of other words in english definition and synonym dictionary from reverso. The application of the rule in turquands case in present. The ultra vires doctrine and the turquand rule in company law a suggested solution this topic has perhaps received more judicial and academic attention than any of the numerous other controversial topics in the field of company law. This is available for public inspection, people doing business with the company are free to inspect the document to continue reading corporate law case brief royal british bank v. Introduction the things you need to know about the new companies act in order to handle the company secretarial affairs of a company. The doctrine of disclosure is the most basic of the company law doctrines as it is the flipside of corporate legal personality.
368 1295 93 426 1188 788 1137 641 258 1463 1205 313 1377 496 1506 1273 223 1577 1548 1640 449 336 970 555 890 1201 367 167 1373 1136 142 1318